yellowstone beth and rip wedding

This episode features arguably the series most romantic moment up till now and also its hardest to watch. Rip is happy to oblige Beths particular brand of crazy, fetching Lloyd (Forrie J. Smith) something old! So she does tradition be damned. Rip has struggled since he was very young. Rip is looking for his boss Beths father, John, but only Beth is present, smoking in a bathrobe. In the short video, folks saw Beth ( Kelly Reilly) feel a mix of emotions toward her husband Rip ( Cole Hauser) who was preparing to head out for a gathering. She tells him that he should have picked options one or two. Beth, never comfortable letting anyone take care of her, is suddenly at her most vulnerable and grateful as a loving Rip just watches. They share a brief smile, and the chivalrous rider takes off into the sunset (er, sunrise). The couple got engaged in an earlier season and fans immediately began to imagine the ultimate Yellowstone wedding. Instead of a grandiose event, the wedding was spur-of-the-moment. We take a look back at all the key moments of their relationship. Yellowstone: Jimmy star speaks out on being separated from co-stars, Kevin Costner once said Meghan Markles acting return would be 'hard', Kevin Costner's director quit Waterworld after explosive fights. Yellowstones Jen Landon left in tears as she opens up on Teeters ranch exit, Kevin Costner speaks out on dysfunctional Yellowstone family, Yellowstone's Monica Dutton star admits happy Kayce ending 'unlikely'. As the band plays on, Rip and Beth dance, holding each other close while the rest of the world fades away. The fourth season of Yellowstone had everything Paramount Network viewers could've wished for - from a Beth Dutton (played by Kelly Reilly) and Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser) wedding to a newfound . You can unsubscribe at any time. When Rip catches up to her and questions her crazy move, she simply tells him she was cheating death. But it was in Season 2, Episode 5 called "Touching Your Enemy," when we got a glimpse of how the fierce young Beth first met the hardened Rip. The two casually hooked up in their teenage years but didn't start actually dating until much later in life. Each knows the other so well, and the sweet moment is comforting. Rip assures her that his future has always belonged to her, if shed only stop running away long enough to see it. I dont give a st about the wedding, Dad. The next, murder and blackmail. Reilly commented on the surprise scene, saying that it's something she'd expect from Beth. Fans speculated there might be something between Beth and Walker, who has a rocky relationship with Rip. Following the brazen attack on the Dutton family that concluded season 3, Beth takes an interest in a 14-year-old boy when visiting her father at the hospital. But Beth spells it out beautifully, and assures him that John already gave her his blessing. "We wanted to team up with a designer who understands what the customer wants and what is on trend while staying true to the show," says Glasser. Not surprisingly, there is hostility at the start. The occasion came close in the third season, but proceedings were derailed due to the attacks on the Duttons. She proposes with a ring that she thought was perfect for him. Rip was a central part of her bad day, and she knows he is always there for her. Smitten by her carefree attitude, Rip decides to turn on all the lights outside the barn and turn on some music. Beth kidnaps a priest on her way to the ranch and prepares an impromptu ceremony in the backyard. She insists on knowing why, and though he is reluctant to open up, Rip tells her about the more than $50,000 he spent on headstones for his mother and little brother. Beth was not cheating on Rip, but rather just expressing her emotions which she often has a hard time doing and didnt want Rip to see. What I like about what [Taylor Sheridan] wrote is that he slow burns this year with me and Beth. Rip and Beth first met each other when they were merely children. Hauser: The first thing it changes is that he's moved into the main house, which is somewhere he's never really been that comfortable. This time, its Beth who wakes to find a still-recovering Rip cooking her breakfast. Weitere Informationen ber die Verwendung Ihrer personenbezogenen Daten finden Sie in unserer Datenschutzerklrung und unserer Cookie-Richtlinie. Yellowstone: Kevin Costners Lawyer Responds To Report That Show May End With Season 5. At this point, Beth is deep into the days coping mechanism: getting naked and soaking in the outdoor trough with a bottle of champagne. Youre not eating? Beth asks. Fans were excited when Beth Dutton, played by Kelly Reilly, and Rip Wheeler, played by Cole Hauser, got married at the end of "Yellowstone" Season 4. Will She Return in Season 5? Though Rip arrived just in time to save her, he took a bullet in the struggle. But there's something that happened in the finale episode that gave viewers the creeps and is freaking people out. You give him your hand if he gives you that., But when it comes to this perfect moment, it appears Rip is anything but ready. Beth and Rips first real date in season 1, episode 2, Kill the Messenger is anything but typical. WearMe Pro Chic Sunglasses Now 31% Off $22 at Amazon Credit: Amazon rosemia Long Sundress Now 50% Off Photo : Courtesy of CBS. He puts the beloved ring on Beths finger. $14.95 $22.95. However, Rip not knowing the whole truth could lead to problems in the future, as it is unlikely he would ever forgive Jamie for what happened. The moment all Yellowstone fans were all waiting for was Rip and Beth finally getting married. Created by Hell or High Water writer, Taylor Sheridan, the western drama series pits the Dutton family against a multitude of outside forces who wish to either control the land or destroy the family entirely. "I mean the way it went down was pretty wild," Hauser said about tying the knot. As an amorous cowboy tries to hit on Beth, Dan comes to her defense and is punched in response. Beth is no damsel in distress, but after Dan leaves, Rip arrives. Moving into the large Dutton home will be something that will take Rip some time to get used to. Kayce is still in the midst of the ritual to find out his purpose in life. Not even Rip knew hed be getting hitched when he woke up! . She asks him why he called her that. Seasons 1-3 air on PlutoTV in the UK. Beth asks Walker to explain prison to her and asks about conjugal visits. Their love story is not a straight line, which only makes it that much more interesting. Ahead of the upcoming fifth season, the cast of the Paramount Network's dramatic Western is teasing how the. Kayce replies, I saw the end of us.. Yellowstone S3 . 10 Facts About the Rip Actor on Yellowstone. With no one to care for him, Beth takes the child home to Rip (Hauser) where the two attempt to raise him as their own. But theres no denying that Summer is going to prison. I just care about the marriage.. Worried that none of his three children are ready to assume leadership, John asks Rip to get rid of the problem in such a way that it never comes back ever. Shes still in that risque gold dress she wore to see Riggins. The couple got engaged in an earlier season and fans immediately began to imagine the ultimate "Yellowstone" wedding. READ MORE:Yellowstones Jen Landon left in tears as she opens up on Teeters ranch exit[VIDEO], When he asked Beth whos kid Carter was, Beth told her other half: I think he may be ours, baby.. You dont need my permission to live here, John admits. The ranch hand was seen digging up the body of his dead mother in order to. Also read: 20 Yellowstone Trivia Questions For Devoted Fans. Emily tells Jimmy if hes having second thoughts, then he better confront it now. Another spinoff series, 6666, akathe Four Sixes, is expected as well, which will cover a similar ranch to Yellowstone's in Texas. "I love their wedding, and it's just so typical Beth," Reilly said. She gives him a choice between walking away or getting intimate with her. The Yellowstone finale begins with Rip waking up to Beth packing her clothes. We arent fing Catholic!), Beth doesnt want to waste any more time. Hewants her here. Im asking you to marry me. In lieu of a honeymoon, Beth her affairs now in order is free to finally take revenge on Jamie for his monstrous decision to allow her to be sterilized without consent during her teenage abortion. Though Rip is skeptical, Beth takes the boy in, believing the ranch will help him become a man, just as it did for Rip at his age. Rip plays John Dutton's right-hand man on the ranch, who shares an on-again-off-again romance with Beth, which came to a stunning new step in the season 4 finale. Carter is there as well, along with John. Beth walks out and doesnt say a word. She shows Jamie that she visited Riggins. Rip Wheeler is a ranch hand on the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch, one of the biggest cattle ranches in the United States. SPOILER ALERTS ABOUND: After the MTV Entertainment/101 Studios drama Yellowstone continued to hit high water ratings marks for the . Kevin Costner stars as John Dutton, the head of a family who has owned the largest ranch in Montana for over 100 years. She later clarifies her actions to Rip saying You know why I always run away? It starts with Rip and John having a serious discussion about the future of the Dutton ranch. How Marriage Changes Beth & Rip In Yellowstone Season 5, Why John Dutton Is The Real Villain In Yellowstone. Rip Wheeler grew up near Miles City, MT, on a pig farm. One day, a wedding. Rip and Beth hurry through their vows and are pronounced husband and wife. Were fing in the dirt, arent we? Beth asks. Walker thinks Beth wants to kill somebody in prison. Yellowstone blunder: Rip and Carter dinner scene picked apart, Yellowstones Kayce star didnt know meaning of iconic scene, 1883 plot hole: Yellowstone prequel fans expose Ennis death error, Yellowstone blunder: Carter won over Beth, Yellowstone's Teeter star pays tribute to key crew members in new clip, Yellowstone blunder: Inside the Dutton family tree, Yellowstone blunder: Beth still had her problems with Carter, Yellowstone's Cole Hauser speaks out on Rip Wheeler's series ending, Yellowstone season 5: Lloyd star delivers filming update on new series, Glasgow explosion: 'MASSIVE BOOM' heard - smoke rises above city, 'It's TERRIFYING' LBC caller tells Farage he's worried EU army will rule UK despite Brexit, SHOCK claim: Trumpu2019s former adviser Scaramucci says Britain voted Brexit for THIS reason, The EU did NOT defeat the Nazis! Like hell, Rip replies, adding that he was born to endure this kind of pain, and he makes the excruciating journey back to the bunkhouse alone as if to prove it. He goes riding with Carter as the day begins again. The judge goes on a shocking rant and tells Summer she wont be eligible for parole for another 14 years. Beth doesnt waste any more time. But it was fitting for the volatile pairing as Beth and Rip walk down the aisle in the ranchs front lawn. Play. With a priest who she kidnapped and her father present as well Beth finally marries her love in a simple ceremony just outside their home. If you can't help me, help someone. Jamie comes to work and has a visitor. You look nervous, Rip, she says. The fourth season of Yellowstone had everything Paramount Network viewers couldve wished for - from a Beth Dutton (played by Kelly Reilly) and Rip Wheeler (Cole Hauser) wedding to a newfound romance between John Dutton (Kevin Costner) and Summer Higgins (Piper Perabo), and, of course, a number of shocking deaths and exits along the way. from $38.95 Quick view. Iris Apfel Drops fresh Animal-Print Washable Rugs, Plus More of the Best New Home Products. I think Ill just watch you. Embarrassed, Beth tries to cover her mouth while she chews, but Rip lowers her hand, insisting she has nothing to hide from him. SPOILERS AHEAD! The judge says it was a necessary message to send to people like Summer, but John thinks what he did was cruel. John, having the power that he does, gets the judge to meet him halfway. After putting him to work cleaning stalls, Rip eventually takes a shine to Carter. Brandon Louis is a TV/Movie news writer. Kayce wakes up and sees the wolf. So if she says that the hat is black then the hat is black.. The wedding ring Rip gave to Beth Dutton in Yellowstone has been a talking point amongst fans for a long time. In this hour, Beth isnt handling the anniversary of her mothers death wellat all. I love you.. By the second episode, since Yellowstone premiered, we already get to see Rip Wheeler and Beth Dutton's romance kicking off. Reilly explained that the marriage will not change Beth as the actor stated that her character's feelings have never wavered in regard to Rip. SARAH ATWOOD'S "TRUE" MOTIVE REVEALED Then, after making a pit stop at a local church to kidnap a priest at gunpoint (call that something borrowed! The couples first official date in season 1 paves the way for a tumultuous relationship between the two. In season 3, episode 7, The Beating, Rip returns home from a hard day at work. If Rip really makes Beth happy, he says, then its she wholl have to ask permission. The first thing she says to him is that he is her father, John's new pet, which didn't sit well with Rip. PEOPLE's 2022 Travel List: 25 Things to Do, Eat & See This Year! It seems like the two might just be his parents, even if theyre not yet ready to admit it. With Yellowstone season 5 set to premiere November 13, audiences will not have to wait much longer to see Beth and Rip back together again. A seething Beth lets him know she doesnt need him telling her what to do. Despite his protests over her, shall we say, unconventional choice of wedding dress, John Dutton walks his daughter down the aisle. But Rip convinces her not to break her promise and run away from him again. Whatever makes her happy makes him happy. She tells John that theres something she has to do tomorrow, and she wants to be a married woman whens he does it. Being together, waking up together its something these two can get used to, it seems. John agrees that Texas was really good for Jimmy. While Beth tells Rip she is not able to have children, she does not go into detail as to why she cant. Its Beth. Garrett is preparing to leave. Despite everything, life is still raging on. Shes kept her promise to destroy anything thats hurt him. When Rip asks Beth what she wants to be called she says wife. However, she quickly takes it back and runs away. Posing as a conjugal visitor. Theres no audience, no music, no decorations, no extravaganza, only two people deeply in love with one another making a life-long commitment. Instead, the pair go to watch a pack of wolves eat an elk while drinking in a car. Yellowstone | 3.1M views, 65K likes, 29K loves, 2.8K comments, 7.1K shares, Facebook Watch Videos from Yellowstone: This now lives rent-free in our head. The actors spoke with Entertainment Tonight about their reaction to the unexpected storyline. First, were gonna dance.. The short but sweet ceremony also highlights everything special about Beth and Rips relationship making the wedding perfect. However, Beth and Rips love for each other grows, and their relationship stabilizes over time. To confirm her suspicions, she visits one of the men responsible. Rip brings Lloyd from the bunkhouse to be his best man while John walks Beth down the aisle. Mia asks Jimmy to choose between her and Emily. He tells her that he wants to leave the ranch, and Beth gestures to his brand (the Y symbol burned into his chest, which means he is forever indebted to the ranch). At this time in their lives, both Beth and Rip are unhappy. You might think it's only because he's seeking blessings from a guardian ahead of their big wedding. 2023 horseyhooves.com, part of the Hopnetic network. With John so close by, Rip is hesitant to hold Beths hand. Before getting beaten, Beth can send a quick text to Rip as a plea for help. Rip turns up the lights and the music. Our First Christmas Married Ornament Personalized Photo Ornament Custom Ornament Wedding Keepsake Gift for Couple Mr & Mrs Gift. Reilly and Hauser's comments indicate that Beth and Rip fans have little to fear in regard to their relationship. Tell me when it saves me. Then, they kiss. In the aforementioned second episode of season four, Rip and Carter sit down for one of their first meals together, with the hardened rancher still not convinced Carter will be hanging around. And tradition dictates that if Rips to marry Beth, he has to ask her father for permission. Do Beth and Rip Get Married? Rip comes up with his own vows and sweetly wipes a tear from Beths face. News how Rip's marriage to Beth Dutton ( Kelly Reilly . The Story Behind Rip's Wedding Ring on Yellowstone and Where to Buy One Just Like It You can now shop what you see on the show, straight from your screen, including the metal band Beth. 'Yellowstone': A Complete Guide to Beth & Rip's Tumultuous Love Story Paul Doro November 11, 2022 Yellowstone may be all about the Dutton family, led by patriarch John ( Kevin Costner ),. Next: How To Watch Yellowstone Season 4: Is It On Paramount+ Or Peacock? This post may contain affiliate links. But the Yellowstone Dutton ranch wouldn . Related: He is played by Cole Hauser, with Kyle Red Silverstein playing a younger version of the character in several flashbacks. Lynelle Perry (Wendy Moniz), leaving the main house after a tryst with John. Beth comes face-to-face with a furious Caroline when she shows up to work. Jimmy star Jefferson White and his on-screen fiance, Emilys Kathryn Kelly will both be back but this time as series regulars. "Yellowstone" Paramount Network. One of these special moments came in the season finale when Rip Wheeler and Beth Dutton finally tie the knot. Yellowstone Fans Were Confused About This Beth-Rip Wedding Scene Moment. Despite his injury, he rises to leave, wincing as he gets dressed. After a fight with Jamie in season 2, Rip joins Beth on the rooftop of Johns house. Fans had little fun with the writing oversight regarding the color of hats belonging to Rip and Lloyd. 1923, a Yellowstone origin story, introduces a new generation of the Dutton family as they explore the early 20th century . And I love you.. We earn from qualifying purchases. This was option three. What followed for the rest of the season was Carter being shown the ropes on the ranch to prove his worth as well as developing bonds with the likes of Lloyd (Forrie J Smith) and the rest of the bunkhouse. To wrap the day in a neat bow, she reminds Jamie that with the photo, Youre fing mine now.. While a fifth season isn't official, with those kinds of numbers, as well as the spinoff shows rolling out, Yellowstone is sure to continue its run for at least a few more seasons, if not many, many more. Paul Shirey is a senior news writer for Screen Rant. Suddenly, Beth asks Rip to kiss her. #Yellowstone #ParamountNetworkSubscribe for More! Beth and Rips long-awaited nuptials finally arrived in the fourth seasons finale, and it wasnt just a surprise to fans. Keep up with your favorite shows delivered to your inbox! But as John Dutton (Kevin Costner) told Beth, she was the one who would have to. In another vision, Kayce winds up kissing Avery. In season 4, Beth crosses paths with an orphan teenager named Carter who she is able to connect with. It's a weird thing to think that John Dutton is actually related to him now through marriage. Although Hauser admits that Beth will face challenges that will peripherally affect Rip in some way, he is a devoted partner to Beth and will always be there to help her through whatever she needs. 'Yellowstone' season 4 ended with a number of jaw-dropping moments in the season finale. But Carter is one of the few to attend Rip and Beths outdoor wedding. When young Beth (Kylie Rogers) and Rip (Kyle Red Silverstein) go on their first official date, Dolly Parton's version of "Mule Skinner Blues" is playing at the local watering hole where. the developments in Beth and Rips relationship. Theyve Had an Inappropriate Relationship For Months, How Black Creators Can Expand Their Network with LinkedIn. SKU:GS5111833.. He responds by saying he doesnt care who she sleeps with, just about her. John shows up at Summers hearing and says he talked to the judge. 1 drama, returns in 2021 on Paramount Network. Jamie does so, only to find Beth there to snap a picture of him disposing of the body. Our readers support us. After Rip tells her that she hasnt aged and just might cheat death, Beth makes a bold move, running out of the car whiskey in hand. Maybe you ought to take it yourself. Beth really does not like being kept out of the loop. He also tells her about the $5,000 he spent getting his murderer fathers bones dug up so that he could scatter them disrespectfully throughout the country. After a quick teasing moment, Beth opens her robe. Just as Rips and Beths lives are joined together, Jamies life now belongs to Beth. Based on the preview, Emily is hitting the ground running at her new agency which means your credit card is about to get a workout. John Dutton, Beths father, seemed to have the most issue with the spur-of-moment ceremony. Somewhere between Proverbs 31 and Beth Dutton Yellowstone Tv show ~ Beth Dutton Tee shirt ~ Bella Canvas Unisex Shirt ~Dutton Ranch ~ RIP . Beth returns home and brings everyone outside. She offers up a third option. The relationship between Rip and Beth has been one of the top storylines through four seasons. In the beginning, there's some wonderful moments between the two of us, some stuff that she's going through in her past, that she's having to acknowledge for the first time, and me trying to help her through that. Inside The Paramount+ Launch Of 'Yellowstone' Origin Series '1883' & All That's Coming From The Taylor Sheridan Universe Grass On The Streets begins with Rip ( Cole Hauser) awakened by the. In the unorthodox ceremony in season 4, episode 10, "Grass On The Streets and Weeds on the Rooftops," Beth kidnaps a priest to perform the wedding. Warning: This article contains spoilers for Yellowstone season 4 Kelly Reilly and Cole Hauser explain the Yellowstone season 4 finale surprise marriage of Rip and Beth. The gang bids Jimmy farewell. Season 4 of. Hes willing to help her with whatever she needs. She was all over the place mentally, from crying over her relationship with John and packing up to taking down those responsible for the attacks on their family to finally marrying the man she. He says that the last few months have been worth everything hes gone through in the past. She picks a fight with her brother Jamie (Wes Bentley) and becomes even further enraged when she spots her fathers girlfriend, Gov. Hes had a day, all right even though he made the right choice first thing in the morning when Beth asked, Should you go to work [now] or should you lie on top of me? But after Rips unsuccessful horse sale and a flat tire, Beth waits while her man angry-chugs a couple of Coors to make himself feel better. Mia watches as Jimmy drives by. "It's made from steel, it is unable to be broken and can weather any storm much like their relationship," says David Glasser, executive producer of Yellowstone and CEO of 101 Studios, of the piece. "Our brilliant special effects team came up with the ring, knowing how important the look and feel would be to the viewer," he says. Once childhood sweethearts, their relationship has bloomed into one of true love. Beth Dutton is trying to build a family in 'Yellowstone' season 4 Rip and Beth have been off and on since they were teenagers, and they are finally starting to build a life together in. It is uncertain, awkward and gentle, but the spark is there. ET. Kayce begins to have flashbacks of his time in the war. You can find out more and change our default settings with Cookies Settings. A proud father, a combat veteran, dog lover, gym rat, coffee enthusiast and all around equal opportunity doughnut devourer, you can follow his daily exploits on Twitter and Instagram, as well as YouTube Videos on The Arctic Ninja Network. Do I still have him? John asks. The ring will be sold exclusively via Shop the Scenes, a new TV platform co-created by Jill Martin, Lifestyle Contributor for the TODAY show, that allows viewers to purchase items they see on their screens by scanning a QR code. One of the attackers shoots her assistant Jason in the head, and Beth is thrown on a table. One fan believes they found a tiny detail that is out of place. The moment all Yellowstone fans were all waiting for was Rip and Beth finally getting married. Confined to bed to heal, he wakes to the image of Beths battered face. Jimmy promises John that hes going to work off what he owes and then hell figure out whats next. Rip, she says, will hunt Jamie down and kill him with his bare hands. . The backdrop was the Yellowstone Dutton Ranch; they got married next to the family home near a tree with her father, Lloyd, and Carter in attendance. Yellowstone seasons 1-4 are available to stream on Peacock in the USA. Youre safe, he tells her. Since the two have been together for a long time and recognize that they are an ideal suit for each other, a wedding was merely an item on their bucket list. (Her language is, naturally, much more colorful.) Thats why he didnt kill Garrett. Rip and Beth go out on a date to a bar where they drink and dance. The boy sits down at the end of the table and Beth hands him his food. Rip and Beth first met each other when they were merely children. It means, Come live your life with me. The only thing I ask is that you outlive me so that I never have to live another day without you. , Its only the things I love that die, Rip, never me. The two slow dance together and share a passionate kiss. He chooses the latter. We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. John also knows thats something Rip wont ever do. John walks her down the aisle. Klicken Sie auf Alle ablehnen, wenn Sie nicht mchten, dass wir und unsere Partner Cookies und personenbezogene Daten fr diese zustzlichen Zwecke verwenden. Though John tries to convince her to wait for a proper wedding (Sweetheart, thats a priest. Beth does not mention that she was pregnant with Rips baby as a teenager and that Jamie agreed to her sterilization without her knowing. Rip invites Beth to go to a music festival, but Beth declines as she wants to do something more suited to her personality. Yellowstone 's Beth ( Kelly Reilly) and Rip ( Cole Hauser) are in marital bliss. The two casually hooked up in their teenage years but didnt start actually dating until much later in life. The savagery gives way to Rip holding and comforting a shaken, furious Beth. I think his love for her and hers for him is one of the very few things that keeps her demons at arm's length (mostly). A good catch by this fan on what might have been a small oversight by Yellowstone writers. Exclusive. Im sorry, Rip, she apologizes. Im stuck here too.. The couples long-awaited ceremony arrives in the final episode of season 4, titled Grass on the Streets and Weeds on the Rooftops, in the most unexpected circumstances. from $26.95 new. Hes going back to Texas. She went out and got Rip a ring that she felt was perfect for him and asked him. As we know, even early on in the series, Beth employs somewhat unorthodox business tactics. Beth and Rip have grown to become an iconic couple and one of the most popular aspects of Yellowstone. While Rip and Beth have both hinted at their desire to get married, a major obstacle stands in their way. Who knew a mouthful of eggs could be so romantic? Being with me is the end of you. Rip gives Beth a heartwarming response telling her Youre all I need., Also read: 20 Best Yellowstone Characters Ranked, In season 2, episode 7, Resurrection Day, Beth is attacked by two masked gunmen in her office. Lord knows you can afford it, she adds. Wenn Sie Ihre Auswahl anpassen mchten, klicken Sie auf Datenschutzeinstellungen verwalten. Another Yellowstone fan has a more logical thought on the hat situation. After their engagement, Beth and Rip promise each other a lifetime and more together. All 23 Rick And Morty Characters Voiced By Dan Harmon, The Menu Theory Reveals Chef Slowik Actually DID Kill Margot, Wesley Crusher Is Now A Big Star Trek Picard Season 3 Question.